Current:Home > My2 Key U.S. Pipelines for Canadian Oil Run Into Trouble in the Midwest -ProsperityStream Academy
2 Key U.S. Pipelines for Canadian Oil Run Into Trouble in the Midwest
View
Date:2025-04-16 05:12:17
The fate of two major oil pipelines for carrying crude oil from Canada’s tar sands region has been called into question over environmental concerns as judges in Minnesota overturned a key approval for a proposed pipeline and Michigan’s attorney general threatened to shut down an aging pipeline under the Great Lakes.
The actions are a further setback for Enbridge, the company behind both pipelines, and for Canadian tar sands oil producers that have struggled in recent years as attempts to build more pipeline capacity failed.
New pipelines for tar sands crude oil have faced fierce opposition from environmental and indigenous rights advocates who fear both the immediate effects of an oil spill and as the climate impact from tar sands oil, a particularly carbon-intensive fuel.
The Minnesota Court of Appeals on Monday reversed a decision by state regulators who, last June, approved an environmental impact assessment for a larger replacement of the existing Line 3. The project would carry tar sands crude oil across northern Minnesota on its way from Alberta to U.S. refineries.
The judges ruled in favor of environmental and Native American groups who argued that the environmental impact statement of the proposed replacement pipeline did not address the risk of an oil spill into the Lake Superior watershed.
The Latest Pipeline Setbacks for the Tar Sands
The ruling was the latest setback for a series of five pipeline projects designed to bring additional tar sands crude to market that have either been canceled or delayed. The other projects include Energy East and Northern Gateway, both of which were canceled, and Trans Mountain expansion and Keystone XL pipelines, both of which are on hold.
“What you are looking at is an industry that has put forward these five proposals and so far none of them have been completed,” Collin Rees of Oil Change International said. “Line 3 I think they actually thought was the one that was almost certainly going to go through, but there has been this incredible resistance. The political terrain has changed, and it’s looking much less certain.”
Enbridge in March had announced a one-year delay of the Line 3 project due to permitting hold-ups. That decision caused at least one tar sands producer in Alberta to hold off on the completion of a US$200 million expansion of its extraction operations due to limited pipeline capacity.
It remains unclear how this week’s ruling will affect the Line 3 project. Enbridge officials said they were “disappointed with the court’s decision” and will consult with state regulators about next steps.
Fears an Aging Great Lakes Pipeline Could Leak
The Minnesota ruling came less than a week after Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel said she would shut down Line 5, another Enbridge pipeline, in a matter of weeks if negotiations between the company and the state’s new Democratic governor don’t reach a resolution.
Line 5 is an aging oil and gas pipeline that can carry light synthetic crude oil, a partially refined form of tar sands crude, and conventional light crude oil. It crosses the lakebed under the Straits of Mackinac, which connects Lakes Michigan and Huron.
The 66-year-old pipeline had lost chunks of its outer coating and appeared to have been dented by a ship’s anchor last year, raising fears of its vulnerability for future leaks that could contaminate Michigan’s shorelines. The company proposed building a tunnel to house a replacement pipeline, keeping the old pipeline operating in the interim, and former Republican Gov. Rick Snyder approved an agreement. But Nessel issued a formal opinion in March that a 2018 law related to that plan was unconstitutional. That led to new talks between Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Enbridge.
Michigan is sensitive to the risks of pipeline ruptures, particularly involving the tar sands: in 2010, more than 1 million gallons of diluted bitumen spilled into the Kalamazoo River from Enbridge’s Line 6B in one of the largest inland oil spills in U.S. history. The disaster forced evacuations, shut down miles of the river and took years to clean up.
“I continue to believe that our state is in great peril every single day that Line 5 continues to operate,” Nessel said in an interview with the Detroit Free Press last week. “And so I’ve indicated that I’ll give the governor a little bit more time to try to resolve this. But if she’s unable to do that, I have independent authority to act and I plan to do so.”
Enbridge issued a press release in response, saying it is continuing discussions with Whitmer and that a new pipeline could be in service in 2024. But on Thursday, an Enbridge executive told the Associated Press the company would ask a state court to rule on the legality of the construction agreement it had reached with Snyder shortly before he left office.
The inability to get new pipelines approved and the potential for existing pipelines to be shut down could have a significant impact on financing for future tar sands extraction projects, said Joshua Axelrod, a policy analyst with the Natural Resources Defense Council.
“If they lose a pipeline like this, the delays, they all send a very negative signal to the finance and investment community,” Axelrod said. “Already the view of tar sands as a good investment is pretty dim and it just continues to solidify that, that becomes a bigger impediment to future growth. If investors are turning away, they can’t grow.”
Editor’s note: This story was updated to add details from a 2015 Enbridge agreement with the state on the types of oil Line 5 can carry.
veryGood! (3413)
Related
- California DMV apologizes for license plate that some say mocks Oct. 7 attack on Israel
- Clean Energy Potential Gets Short Shrift in Policymaking, Group Says
- Hospitals create police forces to stem growing violence against staff
- Economy Would Gain Two Million New Jobs in Low-Carbon Transition, Study Says
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- The Lighting Paradox: Cheaper, Efficient LEDs Save Energy, and People Use More
- Abortion bans drive off doctors and close clinics, putting other health care at risk
- Wildfires and Climate Change
- Will the 'Yellowstone' finale be the last episode? What we know about Season 6, spinoffs
- Turning Skiers Into Climate Voters with the Advocacy Potential of the NRA
Ranking
- Travis Hunter, the 2
- National MS-13 gang leader, 22 members indicted for cold-blooded murders
- Rules allow transgender woman at Wyoming chapter, and a court can't interfere, sorority says
- Study Links Short-Term Air Pollution Exposure to Hospitalizations for Growing List of Health Problems
- Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
- Reese Witherspoon Debuts Her Post-Breakup Bangs With Stunning Selfie
- Overstock.com wins auction for Bed Bath and Beyond's assets
- Economy Would Gain Two Million New Jobs in Low-Carbon Transition, Study Says
Recommendation
Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
Vanderpump Rules' Tom Sandoval Claims His and Ariana Madix's Relationship Was a Front
U.S. Military Precariously Unprepared for Climate Threats, War College & Retired Brass Warn
The Lighting Paradox: Cheaper, Efficient LEDs Save Energy, and People Use More
IRS recovers $4.7 billion in back taxes and braces for cuts with Trump and GOP in power
Colorado City Vows to Be Carbon Neutral, Defying Partisan Politics
Tiger King star Doc Antle convicted of wildlife trafficking in Virginia
#BookTok: Here's Your First Look at the Red, White & Royal Blue Movie